7 views
# Why Your Company's Innovation Process is Broken (And Mine Was Too) [Related Articles](https://skillcoaching.bigcartel.com/blog) | [More Insight](https://sewazoom.com/blog) | [Further Reading](https://croptech.com.sa/blog) The CEO walked into our quarterly strategy meeting with a PowerPoint titled "Innovation Excellence Framework 2024" and I knew we were doomed. Not because innovation frameworks are inherently bad – though most are – but because this was the fourth different innovation "system" we'd implemented in three years. Each one promising to unlock our creative potential. Each one failing spectacularly. And the worst part? I was the one who'd championed the previous three. ## The Innovation Theatre Problem Most companies aren't doing innovation. They're performing innovation theatre. They've got innovation labs that look like Google headquarters circa 2008, complete with bean bags and whiteboards on wheels. They run hackathons where employees pretend to be excited about "disrupting customer experiences" while secretly checking their phones for actual work emails. I've consulted for seventeen different organisations over the past decade, and only two had genuine innovation cultures. The rest were playing dress-up with post-it notes and calling it transformation. Here's what really happens in most innovation processes: someone from senior leadership attends a conference, gets inspired by a keynote about "exponential thinking," returns to the office, and immediately books a two-day workshop with a consultant who charges $15,000 to facilitate brainstorming sessions that produce absolutely nothing of value. The consultant – and I've been this consultant more times than I care to admit – arrives with a suitcase full of coloured markers and an unhealthy obsession with design thinking. They spend forty minutes explaining the difference between empathy and sympathy before dividing everyone into groups to "ideate solutions for customer pain points." ## Why Traditional Innovation Fails The fundamental problem with most corporate innovation is that it treats creativity like a tap you can turn on during designated "innovation time." It doesn't work like that. Innovation is messy, unpredictable, and often emerges from the most unexpected places. Real innovation happens when Sarah from accounts payable notices that customers are constantly calling about the same billing confusion. When Marcus in logistics realises that a simple process change could save the company $200,000 annually. When the reception team develops an unofficial system for handling difficult customers that actually works better than the official training manual. But these insights get lost because we're too busy running innovation workshops where middle managers draw customer journey maps on butcher paper. I learned this the hard way at my previous company. We spent eighteen months developing an "innovation pipeline" with stage gates and review committees and ROI calculations for ideas that hadn't even been tested yet. Meanwhile, our biggest competitive advantage that year came from a casual conversation between two technicians who figured out how to reduce equipment downtime by 30%. ## The Real Innovation Killers **Perfectionism disguised as rigour.** Every idea needs a business case. Every proposal requires three supporting documents. Every pilot program needs approval from seventeen different stakeholders. By the time you get permission to test something, the market opportunity has moved on. **Innovation committees.** Nothing kills creative thinking faster than having to present your half-formed ideas to a panel of executives who immediately start calculating ROI. Innovation committees are where good ideas go to die slowly, death by a thousand questions. **The "fail fast" mythology.** Everyone loves talking about failing fast until someone actually fails. Then suddenly there are questions about budget allocation and performance reviews. True fail-fast cultures are rarer than unicorns, and twice as mythical. **Treating innovation like a department.** [Innovation training programs](https://skillsensei.bigcartel.com/product/assertiveness-and-self-esteem-training-Adelaide) often make this mistake – they try to systematise creativity into neat little boxes. But real innovation is cultural, not departmental. ## What Actually Works The companies that genuinely innovate do three things differently: They give people permission to experiment without asking for permission. Netflix doesn't run every content decision through a committee. Amazon's two-pizza teams don't need approval to test new features. They've built cultures where experimentation is expected, not exceptional. They solve real problems instead of imaginary ones. The best innovations I've seen weren't born in brainstorming sessions – they emerged from people getting frustrated with existing solutions and building something better. [Customer service fundamentals](https://ethiofarmers.com/what-to-anticipate-from-a-communication-skills-training-course) matter here because front-line staff often see problems that management misses entirely. They focus on implementation, not ideation. Ideas are cheap. Everyone has them. The magic happens in the execution, in the willingness to iterate and improve and occasionally admit that your brilliant idea was actually terrible. ## The Australian Innovation Paradox There's something particularly Australian about our relationship with innovation. We're brilliant at practical solutions – ute modifications that actually work, workplace shortcuts that save time and money, common-sense improvements that somehow never make it into official procedures. But put us in a corporate innovation workshop and we suddenly become overly cautious. We start qualifying every suggestion with "this might not work" or "someone's probably thought of this already." It's cultural tall poppy syndrome meeting corporate process, and the combination is deadly for creative thinking. I've run [communication training sessions](https://www.alkhazana.net/2025/07/16/why-firms-ought-to-invest-in-professional-development-courses-for-employees/) where the best ideas came from smoke break conversations, not the formal ideation segments. There's something about removing the pressure and the flipchart paper that frees people to think differently. ## The Technology Trap Every company wants to be "the Uber of" something. They think innovation means building an app or implementing AI or adopting whatever buzzword was trending at the last industry conference. This is backwards thinking. Technology should solve problems, not create them. The most successful innovations I've seen were elegantly simple – often involving existing technology used in new ways rather than cutting-edge solutions that nobody asked for. One client spent $300,000 developing a custom mobile app for field service technicians. The app was impressive – GPS tracking, real-time scheduling, digital work orders, cloud synchronisation. But it took the technicians four times longer to complete simple tasks. Six months later, they went back to paper forms and phone calls. Innovation failure? Not really. They learned what didn't work, which saved them from making the same mistake on a larger scale. The real innovation came later when they developed a hybrid system – digital for scheduling and tracking, paper for actual work documentation. Simple, practical, and actually improved productivity. ## Building Real Innovation Culture Culture change is slow and unglamorous. It's not about installing innovation labs or hiring Chief Innovation Officers. It's about changing how you respond when someone says "I've got an idea." Do you immediately ask for a business case? Do you explain why it won't work? Do you suggest they form a committee to investigate? If yes, you're killing innovation before it starts. The best managers I know respond to new ideas with curiosity, not skepticism. They ask "how might we test this quickly?" instead of "why do you think this will work?" They create small experiments instead of big plans. ## The Permission Problem Most employees are sitting on dozens of improvement ideas that they never share because they assume someone more senior has already thought of them, or because they don't want to create extra work for themselves, or because they tried suggesting something once and got shut down. [Team development training](https://momotour999.com/top-communication-skills-training-courses-to-boost-your-career) often addresses this – how to create environments where people feel safe contributing ideas. But training isn't enough. You need consistent leadership behaviour that rewards curiosity and experimentation. ## Where We Go Wrong We conflate innovation with invention. Most business innovation isn't about creating something completely new – it's about finding better ways to solve existing problems. It's process improvements, service enhancements, communication refinements. Boring stuff that makes a real difference. We also confuse innovation with disruption. Not every business needs to disrupt their industry. Most should focus on incremental improvements that compound over time. [Small changes in workplace communication](https://ducareerclub.net/what-to-expect-from-a-communication-skills-training-course) can have massive long-term impacts, but they're not sexy enough for innovation keynote speeches. ## The Measurement Mistake How do you measure innovation? Most companies count patent applications or R&D spending or the number of "innovation projects" in their pipeline. These metrics tell you nothing about whether your organisation is actually getting more innovative. Better measures: How quickly can you test new ideas? How many employee-generated improvements get implemented? How often do you admit that something isn't working and try a different approach? Innovation isn't a destination – it's a capability. And like any capability, it improves with practice, not planning. ## What I Got Wrong For years, I thought innovation was about having the right processes. Build better systems, get better outcomes. Logical, but wrong. Innovation is about having the right conversations. About creating space for unexpected connections. About building trust so people feel safe sharing half-formed thoughts. My innovation frameworks weren't broken because they lacked rigour – they were broken because they lacked humanity. They treated creativity like a machine instead of recognising it as fundamentally human. ## Starting Tomorrow Skip the innovation workshop. Instead, spend that time talking to your front-line staff about what frustrates them. Ask your customers what they wish you did differently. Look at the informal workarounds people have developed and ask why they're necessary. Real innovation starts with real problems. Everything else is just expensive theatre. The companies that will thrive in the next decade aren't the ones with the most sophisticated innovation processes – they're the ones brave enough to admit when their current processes aren't working and humble enough to try something different. And sometimes, "something different" is refreshingly simple. --- [Other Recommendations](https://skillcoaching.bigcartel.com/advice) | [Sources](https://www.globalwiseworld.com/posts)